Evil Under the Sun
π€| Published | June 1941 |
| Genre | Holiday Mystery |
| Publisher | Collins Crime Club |
| Language | English |
| Series | Hercule Poirot #23 |
πMy Honest Review: Evil Under the Sun
This is the ultimate "summer holiday" mystery. Everyone is at a beautiful resort on Pixy Cove, the sun is shining, and thenβbamβthe most beautiful and hated woman on the island, Arlena Marshall, is found strangled on the beach. Itβs a classic setup. As Poirot famously observes while looking at the sunbathers:
"There is evil everywhere under the sun."
Now, let's talk as critics. The biggest "bad" point of this book is that **if youβve read Death on the Nile, you might guess the killer in the first twenty pages.** The motive and the "fake breakup" trick are very similar. It feels a bit like Christie was playing her "greatest hits" rather than writing something entirely new.
Also, some of the subplots involving drug smuggling and religious fanatics feel like they are just there to waste time. They don't really connect to the main emotional heart of the story. However, the atmosphere is so thick you can almost smell the suntan oil, and the way Poirot uses a "discarded bottle" and a "bath being run" as clues is pure genius.
β±οΈ 1-Minute Summary (for busy readers)
Arlena Marshall, a glamorous actress, is vacationing with her husband and stepdaughter. She is openly flirting with a handsome younger man, Patrick Redfern, driving his wife, Christine, to despair. When Arlena is found strangled on a secluded beach, everyone has an alibi, mostly involving being elsewhere in the hotel or out on the water. Hercule Poirot has to sift through a mountain of "time-table" evidence to find the gap.
The twist? Patrick and Christine Redfern were working together. Just like in Nile, they weren't a miserable couple; they were cold-blooded partners. Christine faked being at the edge of a cliff (using a disguise and makeup to look like Arlena's body) to create a false time of death. Patrick then actually strangled Arlena later. They were "professional" killers who targeted wealthy women for their money, and Arlena was simply their latest victim.
πΉ The Critic's Report Card
| β Rating | 4.0 / 5 A solid, entertaining mystery that suffers slightly from "deja vu." |
|---|---|
| π What I Loved | The pacing. Itβs a very quick read and the puzzle of the "impossible alibi" is handled with surgical precision. |
| π What I Didnβt Like | The predictability for veteran Christie readers. If this is your first Poirot, you'll love it. If it's your 20th, you might see the ending coming. |
| π Overrated or Underrated? | Properly Rated. Itβs a staple of the "holiday mystery" subgenre and very fun. |
π€ Human Take: The Victim's Tragedy
The "human" side of this story is how Arlena Marshall is judged. Because sheβs beautiful and flirty, everyone assumes sheβs a "bad" person who deserved what she got. Even the other guests aren't really sad she's dead. Christie shows how societyβs prejudice against "attractive" women can make them incredibly vulnerable to predators. Arlena wasn't a villain; she was a lonely woman who was easily fooled by a charming face.
The Final Word: Itβs a classic for a reason. Itβs glitzy, itβs sun-soaked, and it features Poirot at his most observant. Just try not to think too much about Death on the Nile while you're reading it!
Discover Your Next Great Read
Handpicked recommendations from our collection of literary treasures
π¬Discussions